Despite spending about $36 million to reduce the subway homeless population, the homeless situation in the subways has grown significantly worse, in part because the city’s Department of Homeless Services (DHS) has neglected to monitor a non-profit that has repeatedly failed to conduct outreach it was hired for, according to an audit released today by New York State Comptroller Thomas P. DiNapoli.
“Homeless outreach in the subway has been so shoddy and with so little oversight from DHS and MTA, that it should be no surprise the homeless population in the subways has grown,” DiNapoli said. “DHS seems to have hired the Bowery Residents’ Committee to deal with the subway homeless population, then walked away. BRC’s failure to even come close to fulfilling its contract has left vulnerable homeless men and women badly served and straphangers fending for themselves in increasingly difficult circumstances.”
Beginning in Jan. 2019, DiNapoli began releasing a series of audits examining MTA’s outreach efforts to the homeless population in the transit system including Long Island Railroad and Metro-North Rail Road. These audits have generally found lax MTA oversight of the non-profit entities it has hired, even as they failed to perform outreach as expected.
The audit DiNapoli released today, examined DHS’ contract with the non-profit Bowery Residents’ Committee (BRC) to provide outreach in the subway and place homeless individuals in shelters. The three-year contract was the result of an agreement between DHS and the MTA to share the cost of outreach, which has since totaled about $6 million annually.
The contract called for BRC to reduce the homeless population in the subways from 1,841 individuals (population count in 2013) by two-thirds to 626 individuals. It was also supposed to develop an outreach plan that prioritized subway stations and report its daily outreach activities to DHS. In 2017, the year BRC’s contract was extended, the homeless population count (1,812) was virtually the same as when it started. In 2019, as BRC approaches the end of its contract extension, the population count is 2,178, an increase of 18 percent over 2013.
Questionable Placement Claims
Auditors found the MTA and DHS cannot trust that BRC is placing homeless into shelters as it claims it does. BRC said it placed 600 clients into shelters since 2016, but auditors determined the organization’s claims were not reliable. Auditors looked at 50 supposed placements and found 20 of them (40 percent) were either not placed in the reported shelter or were not placed on the date reported. For example:
- 6 clients were never placed in a shelter.
- 5 were only contacted by BRC outreach workers and not actually placed.
- 1 single adult BRC wrongly tried to place in a family shelter. No further information on placement efforts was listed in DHS’ database.
- 11 clients were not placed in the reported facility or on the reported date. For example, BRC reported placing a client at Pam’s Place in Long Island City, Queens on May 30, 2016, but the database showed the client was reported placed at the Park Slope Women’s Shelter on Oct. 11, 2017, more than a year later.
- 3 clients were not placed in the reported shelter on the date listed, including one individual BRC reported being placed nine months after the database indicates they were.
DHS’s use of the term “placement” — as initially explained to auditors by DHS — included not just placement as the general public would expect, but also potential placement, including when a homeless individual agreed to go to a shelter at some future time. In subsequent discussions, DHS officials retracted this, and said placement is only counted when someone is actually placed in a facility.
Didn’t Make Station Visits
Based on the homeless population, BRC was supposed to visit stations either twice a week (high risk station), once a week (medium risk), or once every six weeks (low risk). In the Bronx, BRC failed to make required visits to more than half of the high risk stations and medium stations, while in Brooklyn it didn’t make the required visits to one-third of the high risk stations and over half of the medium risk stations. BRC is supposed to give DHS a monthly borough report on subway outreach, but DHS was unable to provide 14 months’ worth of these reports, including 10 months for Brooklyn. In response to the findings, DHS said it would resume unscheduled ride-along visits with BRC workers.
Auditors made 12 station visits (7 announced and 5 unannounced) and found BRC outreach fell short. They were not providing services to the extent possible and in some cases offered no services at all. During four of the five unannounced visits outreach workers were scheduled to visit a station but never showed up:
- March 1, 2019 at Chambers St. (1/2/3) station and Fulton Center station. Outreach workers didn’t arrive for a scheduled visit to these stations, where auditors observed at least 16 homeless individuals, including one sleeping in a heavily trafficked corridor. BRC said it canceled outreach at these stations because staff had called in sick.
- March 20, 2019 at Crown Heights/Utica Ave. (3/4) station and Utica Ave. (A/C) station. Outreach workers didn’t show at these stations for their scheduled visits. Auditors saw several homeless individuals including three men sleeping on benches at Crown Heights/Utica station. Again, BRC said their visits were canceled because assigned staff called in sick.
- May 9, 2019 Jamaica Center Parsons/Archer (E/J/Z) station. Although BRC filed a report claiming 11 minutes (10:10 to 10:21 a.m.) of outreach activity, auditors did not see any workers at this high risk station from 7:15 a.m. to 12:30 p.m. They did, however, see nine apparent homeless (and unserved) individuals.
- May 9, 2019 Sutphin Boulevard (E/J/Z) station. No outreach workers were seen at this high risk station despite a scheduled visit. Auditors observed seven homeless individuals, including one who was disabled, one who was creating disturbances with riders and one who was sleeping on the floor creating a hazard for foot traffic.
DHS also does not make unannounced visits to check on outreach. Instead, they do ride-along visits with workers. During 2018, it conducted just six ride-alongs, three of them taking place in one month. Without stronger oversight, DHS has no assurance BRC’s is actually doing the work for which it was hired.
As DHS’ agent for homeless services in the subway, BRC is supposed to respond to 311 calls within two hours and report on its actions to DHS monthly. DiNapoli’s auditors looked at 121 calls over two months and found BRC didn’t respond at all or responded late to 34 (28 percent) of the calls. In 2017, a change in the format for monthly reporting on 311 calls made it impossible for DHS to assess whether BRC was meeting its two-hour response requirement.
Medically Vulnerable Individuals
DHS’ contract calls for BRC to keep a list of homeless individuals with medical problems, but a review found in many instances it didn’t record enough information to be useful. Examples of entries that gave no insight into a person’s identity simply said “’Multiple Backpack Lady' at the 34th St. Harold [sic] Sq NQR” and “’I’M OKAY F Train Unknown’ at 14th Street-6th Ave FLM.”
While some people may resist giving their names, the complete absence of any detailed information makes it difficult, if not impossible, to follow up with homeless individuals with the most serious needs. DHS developed a database, StreetSmart, to let outreach workers collect as much identifying information as they can, including physical descriptions, partial names, and locations frequented and photos. Auditors found BRC workers kept a binder of photos instead of uploading them to StreetSmart.
CPR and Overdose Training Lacking
Outreach workers are supposed to be certified in CPR and Opioid Overdose Prevention. Auditors found that 19 (29 percent) of BRC’s 66 outreach workers lacked certification in one or the other, including seven who had no training in either. DHS said they would take steps to ensure all workers are trained and able to provide life-saving assistance.
DiNapoli’s audit recommended that DHS:
- Make sure outreach workers meet the performance measures set for them
- Monitor BRC’s work to ensure it is providing sufficient outreach
- Improve controls to ensure BRC’s activity reports are accurate
- MTA and DHS work together to establish targets for reducing homelessness in the subways.
The agency’s full response is in the audit: https://www.osc.state.ny.us/audits/allaudits/093020/sga-2020-18s59.pdf
Find out how your government money is spent at Open Book New York. Track municipal spending, the state's 160,000 contracts, billions in state payments and public authority data. Visit the Reading Room for contract FOIL requests, bid protest decisions and commonly requested data.