New York State Comptroller Thomas P. DiNapoli today announced that the following State Government Accountability audits have been released.

New York City Department of Citywide Administrative Services – Actions to Reduce Carbon Emissions From City Government Operations (2023-N-7)

In 2019, the New York City Council passed the Climate Mobilization Act, including Local Law 97, which requires New York City government operations to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by at least 40% by fiscal year 2025 and 50% by fiscal year 2030, relative to such emissions for fiscal year 2006. Auditors found that the city did not achieve the emissions reductions or energy efficiency improvements for 2025. While the city acknowledged that it was behind schedule due to “unforeseen and unprecedented challenges over the past years,” other factors such as missing documentation, missed reporting deadlines, inconsistent metrics and unclear guidance and communication from the Department of Citywide Administrative Services to agencies it was to collaborate with on emissions reductions also contributed to delays with achieving Climate Mobilization Act goals.

Department of Health – Medicaid Program: Oversight of Electronic Transmitter Identification Numbers (2024-S-34)

An electronic transmitter identification number (ETIN) is a unique identifier used to submit fee-for-service claims to Medicaid. Per Medicaid policy, all entities that submit claims to Medicaid must have an active, certified ETIN affiliation on file before submitting claims. Auditors found that DOH has not implemented adequate controls to ensure that ETIN affiliations meet requirements. As a result, the Department of Health’s Medicaid claim processing and payment system processed nearly 10.8 million claims submitted with 783 ETINs that were not affiliated with the billing providers on the date of service. The control deficiencies identified reduce visibility into the claim submission process, creating uncertainty about whether claim submitters who may have been previously authorized are still authorized to submit claims.

Metropolitan Transportation Authority – Selected Aspects of the Metropolitan Transportation Authority Small Business Development Program (2023-S-47)

In 2010, the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) launched its Small Business Development Program (SBDP) to help eligible small business construction firms develop and grow by establishing business relationships with the MTA. SBDP includes the state-funded Small Business Mentoring Program (Mentoring Program) and the federally funded Small Business Federal Program. Auditors found an overall lack of formal written procedures for many aspects of SBDP, including the application and procurement processes, the identification of bidders and the Mentoring Program’s training and outreach. Auditors found errors or inconsistencies in the documents SBDP uses to select which contractors would be provided with an opportunity to bid on individual contracts. As a result, auditors found eligible contractors that should have been selected to bid but were not.

Division of Criminal Justice Services – Oversight of Adult Probation Services (2023-S-46)

The Division of Criminal Justice Services (DCJS) oversees and funds 58 probation departments across the state, covering 57 counties and New York City. It is responsible for promoting practices that improve public safety, hold probationers accountable, and reduce recidivism. Auditors found that DCJS should increase its monitoring and oversight to enhance the probation supervision practices provided by counties and maximize public safety for all state residents and provide guidance that establishes a balance between the counties expressed desire for standards and the need for flexibility from county to county. While DCJS has developed and implemented protocols to assist counties with their supervision responsibilities, auditors found that counties could use additional guidance and support in areas such as training, caseload and review practices, drug and alcohol testing, completing required periodic probationer assessment reports, sex offender supervision and the management of ignition interlock devices.

Department of Labor – Labor Investigations in New York City (Follow-Up) (2025-F-32)

The Department of Labor (DOL) is responsible for enforcing New York Labor Laws (Laws),which provide requirements related to minimum wage, overtime, hours of work, child labor and payment of wages and wage supplements—and DOL’s Division of Labor Standards (Division) is responsible for receiving and investigating labor complaints, and can assess penalties and fines if employers are found to be in violation of the Laws. A prior audit, issued in January 2024, identified weaknesses in several aspects of DOL’s oversight, including significant delays in the Division’s investigation activities that, in turn, diminished the efficiency of case resolution and restitution for workers. DOL made some progress in addressing the problems identified in the initial audit report. Of the initial report’s seven audit recommendations, two were implemented and five were partially implemented.